NoiseAddicts

the online music and audio magazine

  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Free samples!
  • Music Links
  • Today in Music History
  • Featured Bands

Did Bach’s wife write his music?

Posted on October 20th 2008  

Associate Professor Martin Jarvis at the Charles Darwin University claims that he has found strong evidence that the wife of Bach actually wrote many of his music pieces.

Professor Jarvis from Australia has undergone forensic training from police investigators and has applied this knowledge in an investogation of the manuscripts from Bach’s archive of his famous music.

The evidence seems to clearly show that Anna Magdalena Wilcke, Bach’s second wife, wrote several of the manuscripts previously credited to her famous husband, Johan Sebastian Bach .

Jarvis, who is also conductor of the Darwin Orchestra said “I don’t doubt at least that the Cello Suites are not written by Johan Sebastian.”

The professor first became suspicious about the composer’s music when he attended the Royal Academy of Music in London. He was convinced that there was something wrong when he was playing Bach’s Cello Suites, and finally deconstructed the Suites to come up with 18 reasons why they were not written by Bach.

He said, “It doesn’t sound musically mature. It sounds like an exercise, and you have to work incredibly hard to make it sound like a piece of music.”

Over the course of his research, he found two 1713 manuscripts in Anna Magdalena’s handwriting. This is significant because this is seven years before the two had ever met.

This research lead to Jarvis acquiring an actual Bach manuscript. By using the forensic analysis that he had learned from the police training, he found the imprint of an inscription “Ecrite par Madam Bachen” on the manuscript’s cover, which means “written by Madam Bachen”

“So you bring all these bits together and there seems to be overwhelming evidence that she was involved,” Jarvis said.

Being a woman at that point, there was no likelihood that she would have been recognized as a composer. Had she remained unmarried maybe she would have been, but once she got married, it was this way for all women in society at that point, that they became the property of their husband and their intellectual property was their husband’s too.

We have lots of other examples in music history of women getting married and then publishing the music under their husband’s name. We don’t know, for example, in this great Mozart year, we don’t know how gifted Mozart’s sister was, Nannerl. Was she also a composer?”

Bach married Anna Magdalena in 1721 and died in 1750.

Martin Jarvis accepts there may be some hostility to his research that casts doubt on one of the world’s most famous musicians. But he says he’s determined to continue his work and set the record straight.

under: Celebrities, news
Tags: Anna Magdalena, cello suites, js bach, plagerism

Did you REALLY like this post? Consider sharing it!

digg delicious stumbleupon technorati reddit

« Say it fast: Phonographantasmascope!
Nooooo….! 1000 80’s music videos. »

Related Posts

  • Fan Stalks Singer Alex Gaskarth (January 20th, 2010)
  • I Won’t Do What You Tell Me (December 16th, 2009)
  • Musicians File Bankruptcy List (July 5th, 2009)
  • 100 Greatest jazz albums of all time (May 3rd, 2009)
  • The Heavy Metal Monk (April 17th, 2009)

2 Comments Received

Chano Santamaria
October 23rd, 2008 @8:53 pm  

Interesting stuff and good to see another blog about sound. Will definitely keep an eye out for new posts. Best regards.

Eric Nelson
February 2nd, 2009 @10:37 am  

Very interesting, good read.

Leave A Reply

Please Note: Comments maybe under moderation after you submit your comments so there is no need to resubmit your comment again


Random Featured

    • Great musicians who we lost in 2008
    • Win some hi-end audiophile earbuds by Etymotic .. easily!
    • Privacy Protection - Acoustic Conversation Shielding
    • Cheap Trick New Album on 8-Track
    • Do 320kbps mp3 files really sound better? Take the test!
    • 10 Most Memorable Grammy Moments
    • Earliest Recordings ever made
    • Is Heavy-Metal Getting Too Loud
    • Decade in Music Sharing Technology
    • A ringtone that can give women bigger breasts?

Categories

Search

Archives


Recent Entries

  • Apple iPad – Can it replace your mp3 player?
  • 10 Most Memorable Grammy Moments
  • Mysterious Music Video iamamiwhoami
  • The Best Soundtracks of the Decade
  • Music’s Most Controversial Moments Part 3: Songs
  • Music’s Most Controversial Moments Part 2: Offstage
  • Music’s Most Controversial Moments Part 1: Onstage
  • Fan Stalks Singer Alex Gaskarth
  • Best Headphones Under 30 Dollars
  • Music in the Operating Room
  • YouTube ContentID System
  • Crystal Cable Arabesque Speakers
  • X-Tremely X-Pensive Speakers

Recent Comments

  • DJ DAN VEGA in Releasing (and selling) your own re…
  • Huh in Cheap Trick New Album on 8-Track
  • Synthwerks in Apple iPad – Can it replace your …
  • theavlink in Absolutely Ridiculous Home Theater
  • iodax in Apple iPad – Can it replace your …
  • Dave Whitaker in 20 Best Music Singles of Decade
  • a non e moose in Best Headphones Under 30 Dollars
  • Stranger Dance … in Musicians and bands who use twitter…
  • Ellie in Music vs intelligence: Can music m…
  • saurabh p in Do 320kbps mp3 files really sound b…

Most Comments

  • But can you hear THIS? (111)
  • Do 320kbps mp3 files really sound better? Take the test! (72)
  • The sound that shouldn't be (69)
  • "Hard Day's Night" Mystery chord solved using math (39)
  • Strange and mysterious sounds from the earth (38)
  • Absolutely Ridiculous Home Theater (37)
  • The most expensive speaker cable in the world? (36)
  • Amazing art made with old audio cassette tapes (26)
  • Making house music from the number pi. (25)
  • You want to name her WHAT!? Musicians baby names (23)
  • 70's Rock stars at their parents houses (20)
  • Some of the most controversial album covers ever (18)




©2006-2010 NoiseAddicts